Thursday, December 1, 2011

The Thin Man (1934)

A Dated Comedy

- Some films have comedy that transcends generations, that will be funny until Earth's final hour (such as the Merry Melodies shorts or the Marx Brothers films); some other films however feature comedy that, while certainly funny for those living in the time it was released, lack risibility in future eras - 1934's The Thin Man is one of those films.

William Powell and Myrna Loy star as retired private eye Nick Charles and wife Nora, respectively, who get mixed up in a wacky "whodunit" case when an acquaintance goes missing after a woman is found murdered. Nominated for four Oscars and spawning 5 sequels and a short-lived television show, The Thin Man is often touted as a classic and must see whodunit comedy but my viewing proved it to be an utterly boring and painfully unfunny hour and a half of film.

Certainly not without its strong points - none of which have anything to do with comedy: the beauty and presence of Myrna Loy, the set-up to the mystery, the nice cinematography (by the great James Wong Howe no less), and a particular scene in a dark laboratory are the film's finer points - The Thin Man drags on too long with comedy that is not funny. I am sorry but a film needs more than cartoon-like silly drunks, one particular fat one who wants to call his mommy on New Year's Eve, and a handful of shots of a cowardly dog to be funny. Powell has neither the screen presence, comedic wit, nor plain likability to carry the film all by himself and The Thin Man ultimately gets a poor rating in my book.


CBC Rating: 5/10

5 comments:

yanmaneee said...

kobe shoes
coach outlet sale
air max 90
supreme clothing
nike vapormax
timberland outlet
nike epic react
coach outlet online
air max 95
yeezy boost 350

Anonymous said...

replica bags in london replica bags wholesale replica bags review

shebi said...

Get More Info a3o51j5n25 Louis Vuitton fake Bags replica bags south africa replica bags from korea address f8t22t2v50 replica bags thailand replica bags chicago gucci replica y3m00s3y37 replica bags in london

Anonymous said...

this content replica bags philippines wholesale reference replica bags vancouver site here replica bags lv

Anonymous said...

look at this site j2s62j7r21 replica louis vuitton replica bags canada q4z57o1n06 her latest blog l0t58r5f50 replica gucci replica bags seoul v9e51k6b80 replica bags in dubai webpage g3m68t5n92 replica bags us